contradictions in the personality of de'bel khazaee

there are few  shiite poets or authors who have defended the holy prophet(pbuh& hp) and his household and have not been under various accusations. this paper examines the contradictory views of historians in introducing shiite   poets, among which de'bel kazaee (martyred 246 lunar) is selected. the paper tries to answer  the following questions: considering all these contradictions can one rely on the historians' views in introducing de'bel khazaee's personality? are they possibly prejudiced? are there any statements which reject their views? this paper questions historians' accusations upon de'bel which is in turn answered based on the same charges. the aim is to reveal hidden aspects of charges and compare and contrast historians'  views to leave the judgment to the  just reader him/herself  so that s/he can attain a reasonable conclusion. the assumptions are as follows: 1.these historians' views are due to their enmity to shiite. 2. to detach people from shiite  religion there were forced to invent accusations. 3. these charges are ordered by tyrannical rulers.